Tuesday, February 16, 2010
Guest Blogger - Garrett S.
Is it really all for the best? Does syphilis not matter when you have chocolate? Was the ocean’s one and only purpose to drown you at a certain time in your life? If you ask any of these questions today, people (I would hope) would say of course not. However, in the early 1750’s, when optimism played a very key role in people’s religious lives, they would say it all happened for a reason; it really all was for the best. It was this “blind optimism” that inspired Voltaire to write “Candide”. While this wasn’t his first attempt to raise questions about religion in general (Voltaire’s failed “Poem on the Lisbon Disaster”, was one of his earlier attempts”), it certainly was his most affective piece of literature. But did it really change anything? I personally think it did just a little bit. If the people reading can realize that Candide changes from a blind optimism to a more realistic sense of the world around him, maybe they would too, and begin to question more things, and further fuel The Age of Enlightenment. Also, the ridiculous things that happen in this book could have an impact as well. If someone reading were to say “How can Pangloss say it’s for the best when he has syphilis?” they might look at their own lives and realize that they might have said it’s for the best about something ridiculous too, like say an earthquake followed by a tsunami, then fire, and finally the Black Plague. But those are just my thoughts. Just one last thing! A quick question I was thinking of. If something like “Candide” were written in a modern sense, what would it be written about? What would the issue be? What impact would it have on today’s society? Thanks, and if you have any questions, just comment!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Garrett I really enjoy all your points you made in your blog, speacially calling people out on the fact that everyone has probably thought that something really bad was for the best. I also think (not to offend anyone) that people use God as an excuse. When something bad happens like your grandfather dies from lung cancer because he smoked since he was twelve, some people would say " don't worry it was his time to go, God wanted him to come up to him". NO I DONT THINK SO! It was his own stupidity for smoking that long that killed him not some random divine reason, and it wasn't all for the better. Trust me I'm speaking from experiance. But if Candide were written now I think the best topic would be terrorism and 9/11. That one events has changed everything in the US. Higher security and more limitations, its just one more thing that people can make excuses for. My opinion people are dumb.
ReplyDeleteCadie Engelking:
ReplyDeleteAbout the “Blind optimism”, I believe everyone should be optimistic, because I believe everything happens for a reason, but I don’t necessarily believe everything happens for the best. Optimism is great, to a point. IF it’s taken too far a person can lose a sense of realty. No, it is not okay to have syphilis, even though you may have gotten chocolate. It may make you feel slightly better about the situation, but it doesn’t make it ‘good’. And I also agree with Caitlin, about how some people may use God as excuse and how it's not right. That too might make people feel better about a situation, but that doesn't necessarily make it right or okay.
I like Caitlin’s idea that if a modern Candide were written it would be about terrorism, however that topic is almost too serious. I think Voltaire would write about a more trivial topic like our obsession with celebrities personal lives. Every day on Yahoo! I see celebrities getting married, divorced, having children, or just having a fight. Obviously someone cares about this otherwise I don’t see the point of having it in the top news stories. Voltaire would hopefully show how stupid is to pay attention to this and that they are people too and want privacy. If he wrote it like Candide, I think the public would start to realize there are more important things to worry about like terrorism, or major world and national events.
ReplyDelete